Rug Thoughts

I need your thoughts on this potential rug. It is less than 1/3 the price of the polka dot Pottery Barn rug I want (this one is also PB but is considered a “mat” instead of a rug so it is a lot cheaper). It has the red I am looking for, plus ties together than brown & black I already have in our furniture (and I would have more than enough to pay for it with my ebay earnings). Feel free to let me know whatever comes to mind and let me know which one you like better. P.S. I got a killer deal on some knock-off Pottery Barn towels this weekend at Marshall’s (same as TJMaxx) in the red and white polka dots. I can’t wait to post about them but my mom is getting them for her birthday too, so I don’t want to show them until after she gets hers 🙂 I will also have to show you my adorable curtains that arrived today (my mom already finished them) once I paint the green wall brown.